Interpretations at a Glance
How the Schools Read the Gītā
One song, heard in many keys
One song, and yet it has never been read by a single voice. For more than a thousand years the schools of Vedānta, and the Śaiva and the modern readers beside them, have heard the same eighteen chapters in different keys. Some hear a teaching about knowledge, some about love, some about tireless action. They part most sharply on a single question Krishna raises in the second chapter: when he says that none of us will ever cease to be, does he mean one Self appearing as many, or many souls eternally real and distinct? Here is where they stand, side by side.
Heart of the Gītā
All 12 readings on this one question
A note on method
Each cell is a phrase, not a verdict. The readings of the soul question are grounded in the bhāṣyas on this site, several quoted verbatim from the commentary on Gītā 2.12; tap “the text” under any soul-band cell to see the source. The wider metaphysical cells lean on published reference works alongside the bhāṣyas. Two readings, Nimbārka and classical Sāṅkhya–Yoga, have no commentary on the site and are marked as context. This page is a draft, offered as a map for the reader, not a settled judgment between schools; corrections from scholars are welcome.
Sources
- Śaṅkara: SEP, Śaṅkara · Gītā-bhāṣya 2.12 (Gambhīrānanda) · Brahma-sūtra-bhāṣya 1.3.34 (Apaśūdrādhikaraṇa, Thibaut)
- Rāmānuja: IEP, Rāmānuja · Rāmānuja Gītā-bhāṣya 2.12 · Sri Vaishnavism (Vaṭakalai/Teṅkalai grace)
- Madhva: IEP, Madhva · Madhva Gītā-bhāṣya 2.12 · Mukti-yogyas / Nitya-samsarins (jīva-traividhya)
- Bhāskara and Nimbārka: IEP, Bhedābheda Vedanta · Bhāskara (Bhedabheda Vedanta), rejection of jīvanmukti · Nimbārka
- Vallabha: Śuddhādvaita (Wikipedia, secondary) · Pushtimarg (puṣṭi / maryādā, grace-path) · Vallabha (nitya-līlā vs mokṣa)
- Gauḍīya: Viśvanātha, Sārārtha-varṣiṇī 2.12 (on-site) · Bhakti-rasāmṛta-sindhu 1.2.55 (liberations and bhakti) · Kṛṣṇa as Svayaṃ Bhagavān (SB 1.3.28)
- Abhinavagupta: Gītārtha-saṃgraha 2.13 (Marjanovic trans.) · Gītārtha-saṃgraha: A Critical Study (Wisdomlib) · Tantrasāra ch.11, The Descent of Power (śaktipāta)
- Classical Sāṅkhya–Yoga: IEP, Sāṅkhya · IEP, Yoga
- Tilak: Gītā-Rahasya (Sukthankar trans., Internet Archive)
- Gandhi: The Gita according to Gandhi (mkgandhi.org) · Anāsaktiyoga, The Message of the Gita
- Aurobindo: Essays on the Gita (Sri Aurobindo Ashram)